[Black Cat]

As I understood it, it was not just the "don't blow up the mission" or "Not wanting to heal her" (I was on the quest, though not in that part of the mission). but rather the almost total lack of a single emote from those "Good" characters.

Not a shiver.. or a *averts his eyes from the grisly sight" nothing. No emotions at cold blood murder.

Even if you're FBI agent undercover witness a bloodbath but is unable to do anything or it will blow his cover.. do you really think he will not shivers, have no nightmares, no cold sweat? Even trained soldiers can't always bear the horror of war (and some of them, war I mean, are supposed to be fought for the greater Good).

Sure dark elves are evil and only deserve death. But to take a RL example, even the most fanatical Nazis in WWII, as evil as they were, should/would not be/have been murdered in cold blood... but judged for their crimes... or killed as soldiers on the battlefield. Murdering them in cold blood would just make/have made you as evil as them... or worse for you were or should have been good in the first place. The higher you are... the harder you fall. Hence the fact that those Neutral did not get the evil points.

Just my 2cents...