Dalbarhedi - 6/17/2005 3:34 AMQuoteWintersheart - 6/15/2005 5:54 AMQuoteFinally I don’t think there is one definition on what makes good roleplaying. Different people enjoy different things, but once you have been here a while you should find people playing a style fitting you. Like so many others here I have been playing PnP for many years (longer than some of our players have lived) and I have also taken part in conventions. The roleplaying scene contains lots of smart people and not so few snobs. What we enjoy and what we want all differs, a little less judgement and a bit more tolerance makes it all run much smoother – for both PnP and Layonara. Ah, I suppose I might disagree with you there. . . sort of. At least insofar in that you can at least define what roleplaying involves, but I would also have to say that each individual has varying degrees of aptitude. . . Roleplaying takes a certain amount of talent. Its when people dont even *try* to be in character when they should that I would constitute "bad" roleplaying. I mean, its one thing if you dont have a knack for coming up with a unique manner of speech for you character. . . something else entirely if you have your non-tech fantasy character start talking about calculators and cabs, instead of abacii and wagons.I am not sure we disagree as I am confident we could agree on many cases of bad roleplay, but what I do not believe is that there is any ONE set standard for roleplaying. What cheesed me off was that someone brought along a tape measurer, rolled it out and said: hey you guys are not roleplayers because you run! Some people enjoy socialising in character, while others prefer a more heroic style of play. I know people who would call the first group boring f**ts (pardon me) and some who would call the later hack’n’slash (it can be pronounced with much disdain). Yes roleplaying takes talent (and practice), but like sports it takes many forms and like sports they all share certain aspects and rules (not cheating, knowing the difference between in-game and out-game etc). Pick the one you like and be tolerant of the others, then we can keep Layonara as a friendly community. Rolf Edit: there seems to a quote to many. The last section is my reply even thoug it appears as a quote.
Wintersheart - 6/15/2005 5:54 AMQuoteFinally I don’t think there is one definition on what makes good roleplaying. Different people enjoy different things, but once you have been here a while you should find people playing a style fitting you. Like so many others here I have been playing PnP for many years (longer than some of our players have lived) and I have also taken part in conventions. The roleplaying scene contains lots of smart people and not so few snobs. What we enjoy and what we want all differs, a little less judgement and a bit more tolerance makes it all run much smoother – for both PnP and Layonara. Ah, I suppose I might disagree with you there. . . sort of. At least insofar in that you can at least define what roleplaying involves, but I would also have to say that each individual has varying degrees of aptitude. . . Roleplaying takes a certain amount of talent. Its when people dont even *try* to be in character when they should that I would constitute "bad" roleplaying. I mean, its one thing if you dont have a knack for coming up with a unique manner of speech for you character. . . something else entirely if you have your non-tech fantasy character start talking about calculators and cabs, instead of abacii and wagons.
Finally I don’t think there is one definition on what makes good roleplaying. Different people enjoy different things, but once you have been here a while you should find people playing a style fitting you. Like so many others here I have been playing PnP for many years (longer than some of our players have lived) and I have also taken part in conventions. The roleplaying scene contains lots of smart people and not so few snobs. What we enjoy and what we want all differs, a little less judgement and a bit more tolerance makes it all run much smoother – for both PnP and Layonara.