As the saying goes; 'The proof of the pudding is in the eating'. Look at the server status page, on average there are 10 - 15 people online, and I have even seen it peak at 45.
Not everything suits everyone, so people are quite entitled to their opinions. However, that said, expressing that opinion so as not to annoy, upset or insult others who's opinion differs, is an art. If you cant say somthing nice, dont bother. For whatever reason this guy has found a need to do what he has done, but in the a way that lends little credibility to any argument that he expresses.
On a personal note, I have now been playing Layonara now for the best part of six months. I have yet to see any evidence supporting any of the critisms he has made. I have visited many servers and NWN websites; and yes there are many good ones out there, but for me Layonara has all that I want. So reflecting back to my first sentence, 'This pudding tastes good....'
*licks lips*