I like this idea. Also, we do have Licorice, Peppermint, gum, maple syrup and sugar all as CNR resources, not to mention a plethora of berries and fruits that can be juiced. Honestly you could make most of it out there if we just had cocoa! (mmmm, milk chocolate...) The only downside is that when you combine sugar crystals with hickory arrow shafts and raspberry juice, the end product lollipop would look eerily like the GM-NPC Tool, which might be accidentally eaten as a result.
Here are a couple ideas for recpe templates... Keep in mind this is candy, so each charge will be about as nutritious as a single berry... nature's candy!
Berry Flavored Lollipops: sugar crystals + arrow shafts + berry juice (comes in one variant per berry type, 2 "licks"/charges)
Salt Water Taffy- Salt, Bucket of Water, stick of butter, sugar crystals, fruit juice (for regular taffy just remove salt.. 1 charge/piece)
Peppermint Sticks- Sugar Juice, bucket of water, peppermint (2 licks/serving)
Dark Chocolate- Roasted + Ground Cocoa Beans, sugar crystals, butter
Milk Chocolate- Roasted + Brown Cocoa Beans, Sugar Crystals, Butter, Milk
Brownies!- Raw Cocoa, 1 Butter, 2 Milk, 4 Sugar Crystals, 1 Salt, 2 Wheat Flour, 2 Eggs (makes a tray, 6 servings that come off like pie slices, can make a variant with nuts)
Tarts- Identical to Pies but without a lid and smaller
COOKIES!- Wheat Flour, Butter, Milk, Eggs, Bakers Yeast, Sugar Crystals + either Chocoloate pieces, extra butter or extra sugar for Chocolate Chip, Butter Cookies(which don't use yeast btw), and Sugar Cookies respectively. Can also add berry juice for cranberry, blueberry, cherry and raspberry, and raw cocoa with extra sugar for straight chocolate cookies. Vanilla wafers are nice too... each batch yeilding about a half dozen cookies. Oatmeal cookies? use the basic template and add oatmeal and raisins!
Hot Cocoa- Raw Cocoa, sugar crystals, bucket of water, flasks... makes about 4 cups with 2 charges each, may also restore the freezing meter each sip, as per camping near fires in arctic terrains